Clark (Wheaton College)

    Abstract

    If I wanted to present a high-minded rationale for my most recent version of "U.S. Literature from the Civil War to the Thirties," I'd expatiate on how the purpose was to place more and less canonical works in dialogue, to read not just Hemingway but also Hughes, not Just Fitzgerald but also Freeman. And to try to hear what their works might say to one another: the week that we read Crane's "A Mystery of Heroism," for instance, the class decided--and seemed to surprise itself by deciding--that the character that came closest to being a hero was Chesnutt's Grandison. . . .

    As for student response to the readings, they loved the non-canonical stuff. In fact, course evaluations indicate that, if anything, we read too many of the old canonical stand-bys--a number of students were already all too familiar with Huck Finn and even with The Awakening, though Gatsby continued to have a following. The hands-down favorite reading was Their Eyes Were Watching God.

    The course wasn't perfect. I don't know enough yet--about unfamiliar works, about historical contexts. But that's good too: I know I empower students when I admit my own ignorance and when students--fewer than half of them in this class were English majors--can become the experts on history or music or whatever. Certainly students' evaluations of the course were positive--more positive than for any other literature course I've ever taught.

    Texts

    Required Texts: Paul Lauter et al., eds., The Heath Anthology of American Literature, Vol. 2 (with Whitman/Dickinson Supplement ) Kate Chopin, The Awakening F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby Ernest Hemingway, The Sun Also Rises Zora Neale Hurston, Their Eyes Were Watching God

    General Annotation

    I won't take space here to gloss other features of the course in detail (such as the virtues of having students write discussion questions, which I opted for instead of journals because there were more students in the class--31--than I can comfortably keep up with when I assign journals; or the rationale for one-page papers--another time I'd require three instead of two. But I will discuss one feature that does not appear on the syllabus. I decided to be more experimental than usual pedagogically, to come up with more student-centered activities (I also had trouble imagining how else to fill three meetings a week). We tried a crossword puzzle (to get students engaged with some of the details of "The Waste Land"); we tried writing like Stein (a superb idea in the instructor's guide); we tried small-group exercises in which students ranked four or five characters along a dimension like goodness; we tried debating, splitting the class in two to explore whether Brett is a bitch or whether Janie and Tea Cake's love is ideal. An effective early class, one that helped the group to jell, was one in which we placed Whitman's "To a Locomotive" beside "Pat Works on the Railway" (in vol. 1), listening to a recording of the latter, then singing it ourselves. If nothing else, we could all feel silly together.

    READINGS

    Week #1

    Canonical 19th-Century Poets

    All readings in the Heath Supplement: Walt Whitman , "Prayer of Columbus" (1874), pp. 2818-20; "To a Locomotive in Winter" (1876), p. 2821; "Yonnondio" (1887), pp. 2824-25; Emily Dickinson , 465 " I heard a Fly buzz--when I died--" (c. 1862), p. 2868; 670 "One need not be a Chamber--to be Haunted--" (c. 1863), p. 2882; 712 "Because I could not stop for Death" (c. 1863), p. 2885;732 "She rose to His Requirement--dropt" (c. 1863), p. 2886; 754 "My Life had stood--a Loaded Gun" (c. 1863), p. 2887; 986 "A Narrow Fellow in the Grass" (c. 1865), p. 2890; 1100 "The last night that She lived" (c. 1866), p. 2892; 1129 "Tell all the Truth but tell it slant--" (c. 1868), p. 2893.

    TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #2

    Mark Twain

    TWAIN , Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (1884), Heath, pp. 243-429; TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #3

    The American Girl in Rome

    Henry James , "Daisy Miller: A Study" (1879), Heath, pp. 551-90; Edith Wharton , "Roman Fever" (1936), Heath, pp. 1024-33 TURN IN-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #4

    Passing/Work/Love

    PASSING "Ole Marster and John Who Wanted to Go to Heaven" Hurston , 1935), Heath, pp. 208-10; Charles Chesnutt , "The Passing of Grandison" (1899), Heath, pp. 462-73; John Milton Oskison , "The Problem of Old Harjo" c.1907), Heath, pp. 499-504

    WORK/LOVE Stephen Crane , "A Mystery of Heroism" (1895), Heath, pp. 691-97; William Dean Howells , "Editha" (1905), Heath, pp. 533-42 Ellen Glasgow , "The Professional Instinct" (c. 1916-24), Heath, pp. 974-84; TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #5

    Kate Chopin

    Chopin , The Awakening (1899) TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #6

    A Room of Her Own

    Mary E. Wilkins Freeman , "The Revolt of ' Mother' " (1891), Heath, pp. 148-59; Charlotte Perkins Gilman , "The Yellow Wall-Paper" (1892), Heath, pp. 761-73; Susan Glaspell, "Trifles" (1917), Heath, pp. 1078-87; TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS (last day to turn in first l-page paper )

    Week #7

    F. Scott Fitzgerald Fitzgerald , The Great Gatsby (1925) TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #8

    Jean Toomer

    Toomer , "Box Seat" (1923), Heath, pp. 1478-87; Peer Response Groups for Comparison Paper (bring 5 copies of draft); COMPARISON PAPER OR MIDTERM: EXAM

    Week #10

    (Mostly) Canonical Modernists

    Marianne Moore , "Poetry" (1921), Heath, pp. 1372-73; T. S. Eliot , "The Waste Land" (1922), Heath, pp. 1312-26; Wallace Stevens , "Sunday Morning" (1923), Heath, pp. 1394-98; "Anecdote of the Jar" (1923), Heath, p. 1402; Gertrude Stein , "Four Saints in Three Acts" (1927), Heath, pp. 1196-9. TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #11

    Ernest Hemingway

    Hemingway , The Sun Also Rises (1926) TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #12

    The Harlem Renaissance

    Langston Hughes , "When the Negro Was in Vogue" (1940), Heath, pp. 1500-06; "The Negro Speaks of Rivers" (1921), Heath, pp. 1488-89; "The Weary Blues (1923), Heath, pp. 1489-90; "Big Meeting" (1935), Heath, pp. 1492-1500; Countee Cullen , "From the Dark Tower" (1924), Heath, p. 1512 "Yet Do I Marvel" (1925), Heath, p. 1513; Gwendolyn B. Bennett , "Advice" (1927), Heath, p. 1517; Arna Bontemps , "A Black Man Talks of Reaping" (1927), Heath, p. 1519; Sterling A. Brown , "When de Saints Go Ma'ching Home" (1927), Heath, pp. 1521-25 "Slim in Hell" (1932), Heath, pp. 1529-32 "Remembering Nat Turner" (1939), Heath, pp. 1533-34; Claude McKay , "Harlem Shadows" (1920), Heath, pp. 1559-60 "America" (1921), Heath, pp. 1560-61; Anne Spencer , "For Jim, Easter Eve" (1949), Heath, pp. 1565-66

    TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #13

    Family Dis/Connections

    Katherine Anne Porter , "The Jiltingof Granny Weatherall" (1930), Heath, pp. 1352-58; Willa Cather , "Old Mrs. Harris" (1932), Heath, pp. 1041-76; Meridel LeSueur , "Annunciation" (1935), Heath, pp. 1655-62; William Faulkner , "Barn Burning" (1938), Heath, pp. 1410-22; TURN IN l-PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

    Week #14

    Zora Neale Hurston

    Hurston , Their Eyes Were Watching God (1937) TURN in 1 PAGE PAPER OR 3 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS (last day to turn in second one-page paper)

    Writing & Pedagogy

    One-Page Papers

    The one-page papers are to be polished essays with titles and are to be no longer than one SINGLE-spaced page. In such a paper you should explore in depth some aspect of the work,being discussed that week (e.g., the significance of water imagery, the significance of gender or race, the impact of style, the functions of minor characters, why a given work should or shouldn't be part of the canon). One way to brainstorm for paper ideas is to focus on what you find troubling or puzzling in a given work and to try to figure out why or to make sense of inconsistencies.

    The one-page papers are self-scheduled, though I do list final deadlines for each one. You can thus fit these papers into your own schedule and write on topics that particularly intrigue you. On weeks when you choose not to turn in a one-page paper you will turn in three discussion questions instead.

    Discussion Questions

    You are to come up with three discussion questions--questions that could make for good class discussion. Coming up with good questions is not easy. You want them to be thought-provoking, not merely eliciting factual answers. Think about what troubles or puzzles you. Think about something that might be controversial, something that members of the class might have differing views on. Instead of asking "What is implied by the last line in Wharton 's story?" you could ask "How do the ways the two women have been characterized contribute to the impact of the last line?" Be creative too. Try thought experiments like asking what would happen if the race of the main character were changed or how the story might differ if it had been written by James instead of Glaspell.

    Creative Small Group Projects

    The pedagogical activity that took off in most unexpected ways was inviting small groups (about five students each) to find a creative way of putting the week's readings in dialogue--to prepare something to present to the rest of the class on Friday. I gave the groups about 20 minutes to prepare on Wednesday, and many spontaneously scheduled additional meetings on Thursday. Only after the first presentations did I remember my usual concern for student accountability, and I mentioned that participation here would comprise part of the class participation grade. But I didn't really need to. Students were so excited about their projects that they didn't need additional carrots.

    The projects energized students, engaging them with readings in a new way, getting them to learn something about characters through role playing that they could never learn just through discussion. They also found ways to learn from one another, in this class of very mixed abilities (two-thirds were underclass students but some of our best upperclass majors were also enrolled). I'd more or less expected all that. What I didn't expect was how these projects gave voice to perspectives that weren't otherwise expressed in class, even though I like to think I encourage alternative perspectives, encourage students to be resisting readers--which includes resisting my readings.

    During the week that we read Freeman, Gilman, and Glaspell and the week after we'd read Chopin, one group presented a group therapy session for the marginalized children of The Awakening, "The Revolt of 'Mother'," and "The Yellow Wall-Paper." Another group, in addition to its Sally Jessy Raphael-style interviews, offered brief commercial spots. Two men--in this class where there were seven men altogether, a class taught by an admittedly feminist teacher, and in a school that only two years before had started admitting men--two of these men acted out a spot for a hotline for abused husbands. What pleased me about their skit is that they found an outlet for some of the ambivalence they must have felt when reading murderous portrayals of husbands.